By Mill Chart
Last update: Sep 2, 2025
The Caviar Cruise stock screening method is built to find companies that satisfy the strict benchmarks of quality investing, a strategy centered on buying and keeping shares in businesses with lasting competitive strengths, sound financials, and steady long-term growth. In contrast to value investing, which frequently looks for bargain opportunities, quality investing emphasizes superior operational results, earnings power, and effective use of capital, even when it requires a higher price for better businesses. The screen uses measures like revenue and EBIT growth, return on invested capital, debt level, and profit conversion to find companies that not only do well but also operate effectively and dependably.
PENTAIR PLC (NYSE:PNR) appears as a notable candidate from this screen, displaying a number of traits that fit the quality investing approach. As a worldwide supplier of water solutions for residential, commercial, industrial, and farm uses, Pentair works in an area with lasting growth forces from rising water shortages, infrastructure updates, and environmental needs. Its business is divided into three units, Flow, Water Solutions, and Pool, each meeting essential needs with products including filtration systems, pumps, and pool gear, placing it to gain from repeat business and progress-led expansion.
Superior Profitability and Efficiency: Pentair’s EBIT growth over the last five years is a notable 15.22%, greatly surpassing the screen’s minimum of 5%. This points to both rising sales and better operational effectiveness and expense control. More critically, EBIT growth has been higher than revenue growth (which averaged 3.56% over the same time), implying the company has used scale or pricing ability to increase earnings power, a sign of quality businesses. The screen focuses on EBIT growth instead of net income to focus on core operational results, minimizing effects from taxes, financial setups, or non-recurring events.
High Return on Invested Capital: With a ROIC leaving out cash, goodwill, and intangibles of 78.31%, Pentair greatly exceeds the screen’s need of 15%. This measure is vital to quality investing, as it assesses how well a company produces earnings from its invested capital. A high ROIC indicates competitive strengths, like unique technology or solid brand value, and careful capital use, important features that support long-term increases in shareholder value.
Strong Financial Health: Pentair’s debt-to-free cash flow ratio of 1.67 is much lower than the screen’s maximum of 5, showing that the company could pay off its full debt load in less than two years using its present cash flow. This shows a cautious balance sheet and sound cash production, lowering financial danger and allowing room for dividends, stock repurchases, or tactical investments. The screen emphasizes this ratio to confirm companies are not overly indebted and can maintain operations during economic shifts.
Exceptional Profit Quality: The company’s five-year average profit conversion, measured as free cash flow compared to net income, is 99.67%, above the 75% minimum. This almost complete conversion rate shows that Pentair’s accounting earnings are regularly turned into cash, highlighting the dependability of its income and lessening the chance of aggressive accounting. High profit conversion is essential for quality investors, as it confirms that reported growth is real and lasting.
Positive Margin and ROIC Trajectory: While not included in the base screen, Pentair displays gains in operating and profit margins in recent years, together with an increasing ROIC. These patterns fit the more selective version of the Caviar Cruise screen, which calls for growing earnings power and returns over time. Such advancement often indicates operational superiority, new ideas, or market strength, elements that help quality companies keep their advantage.
According to Chartmill’s fundamental report, Pentair receives a good rating of 6 out of 10, with specific strong points in profitability (score of 9) and financial health (score of 7). The report notes sector-leading operating and profit margins, a sound ROIC, and a good solvency position. However, price is a factor: the stock sells at a higher level compared to its own history, with a P/E ratio of 23.03, though this is similar to the S&P 500 and industry counterparts. Growth measures show solid historical EPS increases but moderate sales forecasts ahead, indicating that future results may depend more on margin gains and capital effectiveness than large sales rises.
Pentair’s match with the Caviar Cruise criteria highlights its fit for quality investors. The company works in a stable sector with foundational growth drivers, shows high and gaining returns on capital, produces strong cash flow, and keeps a careful financial setup. While its price may not attract deep-value investors, quality investing accepts that outstanding businesses often have higher prices due to their predictability and endurance. For investors looking for lasting compounders, Pentair stands as a candidate deserving more review, especially concerning its management plans, competitive place, and capacity for new ideas in water technology.
For those wanting to review other companies that satisfy the Caviar Cruise criteria, the screen is available here.
,
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Readers should conduct their own research and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.
108.83
+1.62 (+1.51%)
Find more stocks in the Stock Screener