News Image

O'Reilly Automotive Inc (NASDAQ:ORLY) Stands Out as a Caviar Cruise Investment Candidate

By Mill Chart

Last update: Oct 8, 2025

O'Reilly Automotive Inc (NASDAQ:ORLY) has appeared as a notable candidate using the Caviar Cruise screening method, a structured process for finding good investment possibilities. This approach looks for companies showing steady revenue and profit increases, high returns on invested capital, acceptable debt levels, and good cash flow conversion. The method highlights businesses with lasting competitive strengths and operational effectiveness that can provide long-term value to shareholders.

O'Reilly Automotive Store

Financial Performance Metrics

The automotive parts retailer shows several traits that match quality investing ideas. Over the last five years, O'Reilly has reached:

  • Revenue growth (5Y CAGR): 5.71%
  • EBIT growth (5Y CAGR): 11.10%
  • Return on Invested Capital (excluding cash and goodwill): 43.23%
  • Debt to Free Cash Flow ratio: 3.29
  • Profit Quality (5-year average): 110.66%

The company's EBIT growth being higher than revenue growth points to better operational effectiveness and possible pricing strength, both important signs in the Caviar Cruise method. This implies O'Reilly is not just growing from more sales but also from increased profitability for each dollar of revenue.

Profitability and Capital Efficiency

O'Reilly's outstanding return on invested capital of 43.23% is much higher than the Caviar Cruise minimum of 15%, showing very effective use of shareholder capital. This measurement is especially significant for quality investors as it shows management's skill in creating large returns from invested money. The company's profit quality ratio over 100% indicates solid cash flow creation compared to accounting profits, offering financial room for strategic plans.

The debt-to-free cash flow ratio of 3.29 years fits well within the Caviar Cruise desired range of 0-5 years, suggesting the company could pay back all its debt in about three years using current cash flow levels. This careful financial setup matches quality investing ideas that value financial steadiness over high leverage.

Business Model Strengths

O'Reilly's business model displays several features appreciated by quality investors. The company works in the automotive aftermarket industry, which is usually quite stable during economic declines as people keep up with current vehicles instead of buying new ones. Their wide store network throughout the United States provides geographic spread and market presence. The company's two-part plan serving both professional installers and do-it-yourself customers creates several income sources and lessens reliance on any one customer group.

Fundamental Assessment

According to the detailed fundamental analysis, O'Reilly rates 5 out of 10 overall, with clear strong points in profitability where it gets a score of 8. The company shows very good return measurements, doing better than 99.18% of industry competitors in return on invested capital. While financial health rates moderately at 5 because of liquidity considerations, the company displays good solvency traits with an Altman-Z score pointing to low bankruptcy risk. Valuation stays high with a score of 2, showing market awareness of the company's quality features.

Growth Path

The company's past growth trends fit quality investing standards, showing steady increases in both revenue and earnings. While future growth estimates seem more measured compared to past performance, the company keeps positive growth forecasts that meet Caviar Cruise screening limits. This shift toward more maintainable, developed growth is common for companies moving from fast expansion to settled market leader roles.

For investors wanting to review similar quality investment possibilities, more screening results can be found using the Caviar Cruise stock screener.

Disclaimer: This analysis is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice, recommendation, or endorsement of any security. Investors should conduct their own research and consult with financial advisors before making investment decisions.

O'REILLY AUTOMOTIVE INC

NASDAQ:ORLY (10/8/2025, 8:07:12 PM)

After market: 101.369 +0.61 (+0.6%)

100.76

-1.09 (-1.07%)



Find more stocks in the Stock Screener

ORLY Latest News and Analysis

Follow ChartMill for more