News Image

MGIC Investment Corp (NYSE:MTG) Presents a Compelling Case for Value Investors

By Mill Chart

Last update: Nov 17, 2025

MGIC INVESTMENT CORP (NYSE:MTG) has appeared as a possible option for investors using a value-focused method. This screening process aims to find companies that show good basic valuation measurements while keeping acceptable results in profitability, financial condition, and expansion. The system fits with main value investment ideas by looking for stocks priced lower than their inherent worth without giving up basic quality, which may provide a safety buffer for investors.

MTG Stock Chart

Valuation Review

The company's valuation measurements show a strong argument for possible underappreciation. MGIC Investment Corp. receives a good valuation score of 7 out of 10, suggesting the stock could be selling at a good price compared to its basic value.

Important valuation measures consist of:

  • Price-to-Earnings ratio of 9.04, much lower than the S&P 500 average of 25.89
  • Price-to-Forward Earnings ratio of 8.82, considerably below the market average of 34.59
  • Enterprise Value to EBITDA ratio positioned more affordably than 83% of industry companies
  • Price-to-Free Cash Flow ratio less than 79% of others in the financial services field

These measurements indicate the market might be underrating MGIC relative to both wider market standards and its direct industry rivals. For value investors, these valuation figures offer a numerical base for evaluating if the stock is priced under its inherent value.

Financial Condition Check

MGIC shows acceptable financial steadiness with a condition score of 5 out of 10. Although not outstanding, the company keeps enough financial power to maintain activities and handle economic difficulties.

Notable condition measurements include:

  • Debt-to-Equity ratio of 0.12, showing little dependence on debt funding
  • Debt-to-Free Cash Flow ratio of 0.80, indicating good capacity to manage responsibilities
  • Steady share count decrease over several years, possibly improving shareholder value

The reasonable debt amounts and good cash flow coverage give a cushion against financial pressure, a significant factor for value investors who usually choose companies with good balance sheets that can endure market declines.

Profitability Review

The company does very well in profitability with a score of 7 out of 10, showing effective operations and good earnings creation abilities.

Profitability features include:

  • Profit margin of 61.96%, doing better than 98% of industry companies
  • Operating margin of 81.07%, higher than 97% of rivals
  • Return on Invested Capital of 11.99%, placed in the top group of the industry
  • Steady profitability over the last five years with positive cash flow from operations

These good profitability measurements are important for value investors, as they help confirm that the company's business structure is basically healthy and able to produce lasting earnings, supporting the idea that current market pricing may not completely show the company's earning capacity.

Expansion Outlook

MGIC displays moderate expansion traits with a score of 4 out of 10, reflecting steady but not rapid increase.

Expansion measurements show:

  • Earnings Per Share increase of 9.09% over the past year
  • Past EPS increase rate of 9.48% each year
  • Estimated future EPS increase of 6.01% per year based on analyst forecasts
  • Revenue increase estimates of 2.63% each year going forward

While increase rates are moderate, they show the company's capacity to steadily grow earnings. For value investors, maintainable increase at acceptable rates can be better than rapid but possibly unstable increase, especially when joined with good valuation figures.

Dividend Factors

The company provides income-looking investors a dividend yield of 2.13%, a bit under the industry average but similar to the S&P 500. MGIC keeps a dependable dividend history with payments continuing over ten years and an increasing dividend rate of 33.24% each year. The payout ratio of 17.51% shows maintainable distribution levels that do not risk financial steadiness.

Investment Meaning

MGIC Investment Corp. offers an interesting situation for value-focused investors searching for companies trading at sensible valuations while keeping good basic traits. The mix of good valuation figures, strong profitability, acceptable financial condition, and moderate expansion forms a profile that fits with traditional value investment standards. The company's place in the mortgage insurance field gives contact to housing market movements while keeping protective traits through its insurance business structure.

The full basic analysis report gives extra detail for investors performing deeper examination.

For investors curious about finding comparable chances, the Decent Value Stocks screen frequently finds companies meeting these value-focused requirements.

Disclaimer: This analysis is for information purposes only and does not form investment guidance, suggestion, or backing of any security. Investors should do their own investigation and talk with financial consultants before making investment choices. Past results do not ensure future outcomes, and all investments hold risk including possible loss of initial funds.

MGIC INVESTMENT CORP

NYSE:MTG (12/15/2025, 10:07:07 AM)

29.035

+0.02 (+0.09%)



Find more stocks in the Stock Screener

Follow ChartMill for more