KeyCorp (NYSE:KEY) Reports Mixed Q4 2025 Results, Stock Dips in Premarket

KeyCorp (NYSE:KEY) reported its fourth-quarter 2025 financial results, delivering a mixed performance that has elicited a cautious response from investors in pre-market trading. The regional banking giant met revenue expectations but posted earnings that, while beating analyst estimates, appear to have left the market wanting more given the broader economic context.

Earnings and Revenue Versus Estimates

The bank's results for the quarter ending December 31, 2025, presented a nuanced picture when held against Wall Street's expectations.

• Revenue: KeyCorp reported total revenue of $2.0 billion, essentially in line with the analyst consensus estimate of approximately $1.98 billion.
• Earnings Per Share (EPS): The company reported non-GAAP earnings per share of $0.41. This figure surpassed the average analyst estimate of $0.39, representing a beat of roughly 5%.

While the EPS beat is a positive data point, the market's initial reaction suggests it may have been largely anticipated or is being overshadowed by other factors. The stock was indicated down approximately 1.65% in pre-market activity following the release.

Market Reaction and Performance Context

The immediate negative price movement contrasts with the company's recent performance and the headline earnings beat. Prior to the report, KEY stock had shown modest strength over recent weeks:

• Performance over the past month: +1.8%
• Performance over the past two weeks: +0.9%
• Performance over the past week: roughly flat

This pre-earnings drift higher may have set the stage for a "sell the news" reaction, where the actual results, even if solid, fail to meet elevated expectations. The pre-market decline indicates investors are likely scrutinizing the quality of the earnings beat and the bank's forward-looking commentary more than the simple top-and-bottom-line figures.

Key Highlights from the Quarterly Report

Beyond the quarterly comparisons, KeyCorp's press release emphasized full-year strength and underlying profitability.

• The company celebrated a record full-year revenue of $7.5 billion, which represents a significant 16% year-over-year increase when adjusted for selected items.
• A critical profitability metric, pre-provision net revenue (PPNR), was highlighted as increasing by $46 million from the third quarter. For the full year, adjusted PPNR surged 44% compared to 2024.
• Fourth-quarter net income was reported at $474 million, or $0.43 per diluted common share.

These figures paint a picture of a bank that has successfully navigated a challenging interest rate environment to grow its top line and core earnings power substantially over the past year.

Looking Ahead: Analyst Estimates for 2026

The press release did not provide formal forward-looking guidance, which is a neutral factor and does not explain the market's reaction. However, current analyst estimates for the coming year suggest expectations for a period of normalization.

• For the full year 2026, analysts are projecting revenue of approximately $8.04 billion and EPS of about $1.80.
• For the immediate next quarter (Q1 2026), the consensus calls for revenue of $1.94 billion and EPS of $0.41.

The Q1 EPS estimate of $0.41 matches the result just delivered for Q4 2025, implying analysts expect earnings to hold steady in the near term rather than continue the previous year's rapid growth trajectory. Investors will be listening closely to management's commentary on the earnings call for clues on whether the bank can continue to expand profitability or if it faces headwinds from potential interest rate cuts or credit normalization.

For a detailed breakdown of KeyCorp's historical earnings, future estimates, and analyst revisions, you can review the data here.

---

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice, a recommendation, or an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities. The information presented is based on data believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed. Investors should conduct their own research and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions.