Bristol-Myers Squibb Co (NYSE:BMY) Presents a Compelling Value Investment Case

By Mill Chart - Last update: Dec 2, 2025

Article Mentions:

For investors looking for chances where a company's market price seems separate from its basic financial soundness, a methodical value method can be a useful rule. This process involves searching for stocks that sell at appealing prices—frequently judged by measures like price-to-earnings ratios—while also showing good basics in parts like earnings, balance sheet strength, and expansion. The aim is to find possibly underrated securities before the wider market sees their value. A recent search for "reasonable value" stocks, which selects for strong price ratings together with adequate marks in other basic groups, has pointed to Bristol-Myers Squibb Co (NYSE:BMY) as a name that deserves more study.

BMY Stock Chart

A Close Look at Price Measures

The foundation of any value investment idea is an appealing price compared to the company's income and cash generation. Bristol-Myers Squibb does very well here, receiving a leading ChartMill Price Rating of 9 out of 10. A close review of the fundamental analysis report shows the reason for this mark.

  • Price-to-Earnings (P/E) Ratio: At 7.50, BMY's P/E ratio is much lower than the S&P 500 average of about 26.11, and it also makes the company less expensive than almost 94% of similar firms in the pharmaceuticals field.
  • Forward P/E Ratio: The price stays interesting looking forward, with a Price/Forward Earnings ratio of 8.08. This shows a very reasonable price, less expensive than 90% of industry rivals.
  • Cash Flow and EBITDA Multiples: The good price goes further than income. The company's Enterprise Value to EBITDA and Price/Free Cash Flow ratios are also less expensive than about 95% and 94% of the industry, in that order.

For a value investor, these numbers point to a large safety buffer. The market is now valuing BMY at a large reduction compared to both the wider market and its own industry, even with the company's settled business.

Evaluating Balance Sheet Strength and Earnings Power

A low price by itself can be misleading if the company's financial base is poor. So, the search rules require adequate marks in balance sheet strength and earnings power. BMY shows a varied but generally okay image here, which helps explain its low price.

Balance Sheet Strength (Rating: 5/10): The company's balance sheet strength rating is middling, pointing to some good points balanced by watch points.

  • Good Points: BMY is producing value, as its Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) is higher than its cost of capital. Its Debt to Free Cash Flow ratio of 3.20 is good, showing it could pay off all debt in just over three years using its present cash flow—a number better than 87.5% of similar firms.
  • Points to Watch: The balance sheet has a high amount of debt, with a Debt/Equity ratio of 2.41, which is poorer than most industry rivals. Liquidity ratios, like the Current and Quick ratios, are also under industry averages. This means that while the company produces plenty of cash, its funding setup is bold.

Earnings Power (Rating: 7/10): BMY's earnings power is a definite positive, which is key for a value stock as it confirms the business works well and can produce returns.

  • The company has very good returns on capital, with a Return on Equity of 32.55% and an ROIC of 18.43%, both numbers in the top 5% of the pharmaceuticals field.
  • Margins are solid. An Operating Margin of 33.51% and a Profit Margin of 12.57% are better than most peers.

This good earnings power picture supports the investment view. It shows that the reduced price is not a sign of a failing business, but instead a market missing a company that is very good at turning sales into profit.

Expansion Outlook and Dividend Attraction

Value investing does not forget expansion; it looks for acceptable expansion at an acceptable price. BMY's expansion story is one of change, with a high dividend payment adding to its possible overall return.

Expansion (Rating: 5/10): The expansion rating is neutral, showing a history of large acquisition-led combination and a future dealing with patent losses.

  • Past & Future Income: While the past five years show an average drop in Earnings Per Share (EPS), the last year saw a large 460% growth, partly changing the starting point. More importantly, experts predict good forward EPS growth of over 35% each year for the next few years.
  • Sales Difficulties: The main worry is in sales, which are expected to fall by almost 5% each year based on present guesses, probably because of coming patent ends on important drugs. This expected drop is a main reason for the stock's low price.

Dividend (Rating: 8/10): The dividend is a notable point for investors focused on income.

  • BMY gives a large yearly dividend payment of 5.04%, which is over two times the S&P 500 average and in the top group of its field.
  • The dividend has a steady 10-year history and has been increasing at a strong yearly rate of almost 12%.

For a steady investor, the high, growing dividend gives a real return while waiting for the market to possibly revalue the stock or for the company's new drug lineup to make up for sales drops.

Final Thoughts: A Price Case in Change

Bristol-Myers Squibb shows a standard value investment situation: a financially sound and very profitable company selling at a large discount because of clear, short-term difficulties—mainly coming patent losses. The search method correctly found BMY because its price numbers are very low, while its earnings power stays very good and its balance sheet strength, though debt-heavy, is backed by good cash flow. The high dividend payment adds to the safety buffer and possible overall return.

The investment idea depends on whether the market has been too harsh on the stock for its known problems and has not valued its development pipeline, earnings power, and capital return enough. It is a stock fitting for investors who think the present price fully accounts for the risks and are ready to be paid with a high yield as the company manages its change.

Find Other Possible Price Chances This review of Bristol-Myers Squibb came from a systematic search for stocks with strong price ratings and adequate basics. If you want to look into other companies that match this "reasonable value" description, you can use the same search here.

,

Disclaimer: This article is for information only and is not financial advice, a suggestion, or a bid or request to buy or sell any securities. The information given is based on supplied data and should not be the only ground for any investment choice. Investing has risk, including the possible loss of the original amount. Always do your own research and think about talking with a skilled financial advisor before making any investment choices.

BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB CO

NYSE:BMY (2/12/2026, 8:04:00 PM)

After market: 59.8493 -0.01 (-0.02%)

59.86

-0.07 (-0.12%)



Find more stocks in the Stock Screener

Follow ChartMill for more
Follow us on StockTwitsFollow us on InstagramFollow us on FacebookFollow us on YouTube