Anglogold Ashanti PLC (NYSE:AU) Presents a Compelling Value Investment Case

By Mill Chart - Last update: Dec 19, 2025

Article Mentions:

For investors aiming to construct a portfolio using value investing principles, the central method requires finding companies selling for less than their inherent worth. This method, established by Benjamin Graham and notably used by Warren Buffett, aims to purchase shares of fundamentally strong businesses when they are temporarily unpopular or missed by the market. The objective is to establish a margin of safety, a cushion between the price paid and the calculated true value of the company. A systematic method to look for these chances is by filtering for stocks that display good basic financial condition and earnings, but are available at a lower price based on important valuation measures. One such possibility found through this analysis is Anglogold Ashanti PLC (NYSE:AU).

Anglogold Ashanti PLC (AU) Stock Image

Examining the Basics

Anglogold Ashanti, an international gold mining company with activities in four continents, shows an interesting profile when assessed with a value-investing perspective. According to ChartMill's detailed fundamental analysis report, the company receives an overall fundamental score of 8 out of 10, a good score that is broken down into high grades across the important groups of valuation, growth, earnings, and financial condition. This even strength is exactly what value investors search for: a company that is not only low-priced, but low-priced without a clear cause compared to its solid operational results.

Valuation: The Foundation of the Chance

The most direct appeal for a value investor is the stock's price assessment. The ChartMill Valuation Score for AU is a high 8, signaling the market could be pricing the company's future cash flows and earnings potential too low.

  • Good Earnings Multiples: While the standard Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio of 19.61 may seem average, the more anticipatory Price-to-Forward Earnings ratio is at a quite low 10.15. This implies the market is valuing current earnings without fully accounting for future expansion.
  • Industry and Market Price Difference: Importantly, both the P/E and forward P/E ratios are lower than those of about 85% of similar companies in the Metals & Mining industry. Also, AU sells for less than the wider S&P 500 average on these measures, presenting a possible value chance within the larger market setting.
  • Cash Flow Performance: The company's valuation seems even more interesting when looking at cash generation. AU's Price-to-Free Cash Flow ratio is more favorable than over 90% of its industry rivals, emphasizing that the market could be underestimating the good cash the business generates.

For a value investor, these measures are the beginning. A low price assessment alone can be misleading. The essential question is whether the low price is explained by weak basics, or if it indicates a pricing error for a sound company.

Earnings and Financial Condition: Confirming Quality

Value investing is not only about purchasing inexpensive stocks; it is about purchasing sound companies at an inexpensive price. AU's fundamental report verifies the quality of the basic business.

Earnings are notable, with a score of 8. The company shows very good margins and returns on capital:

  • Its Profit Margin of 24.58% and Operating Margin of 37.97% are better than almost 90% of the industry.
  • Returns on Assets (16.68%) and Equity (32.17%) are in the highest group of its field, signaling very effective use of its capital to produce profits.

Financial Condition is also firm, with a score of 7. A sound balance sheet lowers risk and offers stability, which is crucial for the margin of safety idea.

  • The company maintains a workable Debt-to-Equity ratio and, more significantly, a very good Debt-to-Free Cash Flow ratio of 0.92. This means it could pay off all its debt in under a year using its present cash flow, a position of notable strength.
  • Liquidity is adequate, with a Current Ratio of 2.58, confirming it can easily meet near-term responsibilities.

This pairing of high earnings and firm condition signals AU is a financially stable operator, not a troubled company whose low price indicates basic weakness.

Growth: The Driver for Value Recognition

For the undervaluation difference to shrink, the company needs a driver, often supplied by expansion. AU's Growth Score of 8 suggests it has this driver active.

  • Previous Results: The company has demonstrated notable recent expansion, with Earnings Per Share increasing over 517% in the last year and Revenue expanding by 26.43%. Longer-term patterns are also good, with average yearly EPS and Revenue growth in the double digits.
  • Future Predictions: Analysts anticipate this progress to persist, forecasting average yearly EPS growth of almost 15% and Revenue growth of over 13% in the next years. This quickening expansion pattern can act as the force that prompts market reassessment and a increased stock price.

Summary

Anglogold Ashanti PLC presents a situation that matches main value investing ideas. It seems to be a high-quality, profitable business with a firm balance sheet and a positive expansion path, yet it is valued at a lower price compared to both its industry and the wider market. This separation between price and basic results is precisely what value filters are made to find. While the gold mining field involves natural commodity price uncertainties, AU's operational strength and valuation measures indicate it may provide the margin of safety that careful value investors look for.

This assessment of AU was obtained from a methodical search for "reasonable value" stocks. If you want to examine other companies that fit similar standards of fair valuation, firm earnings, condition, and growth, you can see the complete filter results here.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security. Investing involves risk, including the potential loss of principal. You should conduct your own research and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

ANGLOGOLD ASHANTI PLC

NYSE:AU (2/13/2026, 8:04:00 PM)

After market: 109.8 -0.02 (-0.02%)

109.82

+5.09 (+4.86%)



Find more stocks in the Stock Screener

Follow ChartMill for more
Follow us on StockTwitsFollow us on InstagramFollow us on FacebookFollow us on YouTube